When working with historic properties, re-enameling a tub is a good option for keeping the period-specific look.
- However, despite the variety of tub resurfacing products on the retailer's shelf, I would discourage you from taking on this task yourself.
- It is a noxious process that is prone to failure (chipping, peeling, etc.) when performed by a novice.
- Look for resurfacing companies in your area, then check with the Better Business Bureau to find a local reputable firm.
Regarding liners, they are typically made of a low-durability fiberglass (not a terribly eco-friendly material) and are prone to offgassing when first installed.
Additionally, a liner will not deliver the architectural look that resurfacing can.
Consider dressing up the surround
Lastly, if the finish on the existing tub is in good condition, you might want to consider "dressing up" the tub surround with some of today's fabulous recycled glass tiles, allowing you to make the most of the seafoam green color.
As with most home renovation projects, your ultimate decision should be based on the materials' ease of maintenance, the cost, and the aesthetic appeal.
For more information:
- Read "What's less toxic: refinishing an old cast-iron tub or getting a fiberglass tub?" a Q&A answered by Molly McCabe.
- Read "A contractor told us he would use a low-VOC acrylic urethane to refinish our cast-iron tub. Does such a product exist?" a Q&A answered by Bill Bradbury.
- "Are there non- or less-toxic bathtubs?" a Q&A answered by Karen Smuland.
- "I have a bathtub that needs re-enameling. Is there a nontoxic way to do this?" a Q&A answered by Mick Dalrymple.